In a significant legal victory for freedom of expression, a federal appeals court has struck down San Diego’s ban on yoga classes in public parks and beaches. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on June 4th that the ban is unconstitutional, affirming the protected status of yoga instruction under the First Amendment.

The court’s decision highlights the city’s failure to demonstrate a legitimate connection between yoga classes and any threat to public safety or enjoyment of city parks. The ban, stemming from an amended ordinance targeting street vendors, also prohibited other commercial activities without permits, impacting yoga classes with four or more participants.

This ruling is a clear win for proponents of free speech and access to public spaces. It emphasizes the importance of protecting constitutionally protected activities, even those that might involve commercial elements, from overly restrictive local regulations. The case underscores the need for cities to carefully consider the impact of their ordinances on fundamental rights.